Holli A. Semetko and Natalya Krasnoboka, "The Political
Role of the Internet in Societies in Transition: Russia and
Ukraine Compared," Party Politics, 9 (January 2003),
77-104.
First Paragraph:
From its beginning, the Internet was thought of as having
great potential and likely to improve democracy, empower
citizens and enhance public engagement with politics (Mann,
1995; Rheingold, 1993). The experience of the first
elections in which the Internet was a part, however, led
some researchers to recognize that it could also enhance
existing divisions of power in society and create new gaps
between the information haves and have-nots (Davis, 1999;
Margolis et al., 1997; Selnow, 1998).
Figures and Tables:
Table 1: Party competition on the Internet: Russia and
Ukraine (as of January 2001)
Table 2: Quality of the websites
Figure 1: Political news competition on the Internet in
Russia, December 2000-January 2001
Figure 2: Political news competit6ion on the Internet in
Ukraine, December 2000-January 2001
Appendix A: Characteristics of political parties/blocks
elected to the Russian parliament
Appendix B: Characteristics of political parties/blocks
elected to the Ukraine parliament
Last Paragraph:
Whereas journalists in established democracies have
considerable freedom to criticize the government of the day,
in Russia and Ukraine and many societies in transition, this
kind of behaviour can result in a variety of forms of
pressure being brought to bear on the individual journalist
and/or news organization. In 2001, the Committee on Culture,
Science and Education (2001) in the Assembly of the Council
of Europe (CoE) reported numerous cases of violence against
journalists and human rights abuses in CoL member countries.
Ukraine was mentioned as one of several countries that still
has legislation permitting the government to imprison a
journalist for voicing his or her opinions. The report
singles out the tragic case of online journalist Georgy
Gongadze and calls for the government to complete a proper
investigation of the circumstances surrounding his
disappearance and alleged murder. According to Cherribi (in
press), in these societies in transition: ~Censorship is not
only brought about through violence. Legitimate arms of the
state are often used to intimidate journalists and media
organizations'. Arms of the state include the tax office,
police and fire inspection officials, for example. For those
who are opposed to or critical of governing authorities, it
is under these most threatening of circumstances that the
Internet provides an opportunity for communication and for
obtaining information that would not otherwise be found in
traditional media outlets.
|